Income isn’t everything – part 1

I don’t agree with your article, It’s all about income. People who sat through the 2007 – 2009 massive bear market falls lost 50+% of their capital. It will take them many years to recover. I did far better by moving to cash and bonds for 2 years then returning to the market. I know you will say it is hard to time the market…but the major bear markets are flaming obvious when they happen.

A: Thanks for your email. We’re all entitled to our views and I’m very pleased you mentioned this point.


No so-called economic expert – eg at our RBA or the US Fed – saw the recent GFC coming. If you recognised that and 1987 then, well done!


I have a few questions for you which I very much hope you’ll be able to answer:



  1. If Aussie shares fell by 50% during the recent correction, what did the ASX 200 All Ords income paid (exclude franking credits if you like) fall by?

  2. Has your cash investment income increased by at least the inflation level?

  3. Has the income paid by ASX 200 All Ords company’s retuned to pre-GFC levels?


Best Regards,


Read the response here.



Read Answer